WTF, DC? Bette Kane, Part Two

In the 10 years between her “introduction” in Secret Origins Annual #3 and her bit part in the JLA/Titans miniseries in 1999, Bette Kane made a whopping five appearances in the DCU. That’s once every two years, and it was usually a fleeting glimpse of her amongst a larger superhero crowd.

JLA/Titans wasn’t much different – it was pretty jam-packed with Titans and Leaguers – but it did manage to showcase Bette’s obsession with Robin by portraying her as an absurdly horny cartoon:

In the following issue she sums up Nightwing’s appeal by saying, “It’s his butt!” Incidentally, 1999 was the height of Spice Girls girl-power pseudo-feminism, so maybe the writers of JLA/Titans thought they being progressive. Though Phil Jiminez and Devin Grayson shared writing duties, I’m going to guess that this characterization/dialogue was Grayson’s doing (see her subsequent 20-issue run on The Titans for further evidence of how completely off-the-mark her writing could be).

A year later, Titan veteran Beast Boy would get his own four-issue mini, in which Bette was prominently featured. At first, it was business as usual, with Bette’s crush wavering somewhere between awkward and overbearing, until Nightwing tells her he’s just not that into her (and that she shouldn’t quit her day job):

But the Beast Boy mini was actually a tale of redemption for Bette Kane. She decided she was so over that loser Dick Grayson – what was she thinking? – and that adventuring would totes be her number-one priority from now on:

Which is all well and good, but…take a close look at her costume. Notice anything? That torso’s almost like a gold-and-red version of Nightwing’s isn’t it? No? Maybe not? Maybe it’s a coincidence.

A few years later, Flamebird would be among the Titans called to battle Superboy-Prime during Infinite Crisis. At the same time, Earth-2 Superman was busy recreating his adopted homeworld in the hopes it would help revive his dying wife Lois, an act that transported all of the Earth-2 heroes back to their proper universe. Among them was…Bette Kane?

Yeah…why did you go there, Bette? DC had taken great pains to assure us you were a new, different character from Betty Kane, and even if you were Betty Kane, it wouldn’t matter because Bat-Girl was never part of Earth-2. She never appeared in Earth-2 stories and Betty/Bette Kane was from Earth-1 before and after Crisis on Infinite Earths. So this is confusing.

A little while after this, a new Batwoman was introduced in the year-long weekly series 52. While it was clear this was a new take on the character – she’s redheaded and a lesbian, whereas her predecessor was brunette and desperately heterosexual – her name is Kate Kane. The previous Batwoman was named Kathy Kane. Gumming up the works is the fact that Kate’s stepmother is named Catherine Kane (though Catherine, it’s pointed out, is not the previous Batwoman). Kate, to the delight of nostalgic fans, was revealed to be the cousin of none other than Bette Kane. So Batwoman and Bat-Girl, er, Flamebird, were together again after 40 years! Sort of! And then Grant Morrison decided to do this:

Yes, that’s Kate Kane Batwoman fighting a Kathy Kane Batwoman imposter in the pages of Batman Incorporated. Now, the only way for Earth-2 Bette Kane to somehow function as cousin to Earth-1 Kate Kane would be to pretend Kathy Kane had never existed. Just never mention her. Never even hint that she existed in any way, shape, or form, or the whole house of cards would come tumbling down. But…there she is.

How is Kate Kane cousin to Bette Kane? Is Kate Kane from Earth-2? Is this Bette Kane actually from Earth-1? An Earth-1 where the Kathy Kane Batwoman existed but Betty Kane Bat-Girl didn’t? Was the Infinite Crisis Earth-2 Flamebird eaten by wolves, necessitating an Earth-1 replacement? And how many Kane women have the same goddamn name? I should also mention that Kate Kane has a twin sister named Elizabeth “Beth” Kane.

Still, the new version of Flamebird that debuted alongside Batwoman was pretty badass:

Bette convinces Kate to train her in the deadly art of redhead military lesbian asskick-fu, with the end goal being that the cousins would fight alongside each other on the streets of Gotham City. Kate’s all for it, until she realizes, in Batwoman #3, that things are dangerous enough for her, let alone her semi-sheltered cousin. Kate gives Bette a Nightwing-style dressing-down, and Bette responds the same way she did before: by ignoring the advice she’s been given, designing a new costume, and rebelliously leaping into the fray:

At least that one aspect of Bette Kane’s character is consistent.

UPDATE: I somehow missed the fact that the wife of Bob Kane, long credited as Batman’s creator despite ample evidence to the contrary, was also named Elizabeth Kane. Yikes.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to WTF, DC? Bette Kane, Part Two

  1. ToB says:

    Great blog! I can’t wait to read some of your back posts. I like Bette a lot and think she’s badly underrated. The only reason I would pick up the current Batwoman series would be for Bette. I wish they would revive a variant of the old Titans West with Lilith, Gar, Bette and Hank and Dawn and Mal and Karen. Thank you for going to the trouble of highlighting all the DC nightmares. Ironically, Didio and Johns would likely say that the discontinuities in continuity and characterization problems you’re describing are the perfect reasons for erasing everything. Except – they’re not erasing everything, and they’re just adding their own new version of wtf to the already messed pile. I have several pieces on what DC did to the Titans and other heroes on my blog, and I have a big character continuity for Terra. Hope you’ll check them out.

  2. Gerardo says:

    I find the inconsistence cool, I like what Morrison did in Batman inc So what if he fucked continuity? Since when continuity is the word of good in DCU?

  3. ToB says:

    I find it kind of amazing that some fans are hailing the latest issue of Batwoman from earlier this month as progress for Bette, a sign that she’ll finally be taken seriously. It looks a little more to me like another Titan being broken down to build up an A- or B-lister. I think Batwoman is the main character in that title, although truthfully the only reason a lot of people are reading it is for Bette.

  4. J.H. Williams is a pretty stunning artist and he can write (a 2-in-1 combo that’s extremely rare), which is why I’d pick up Batwoman even if Flamebird never made an appearance. Don’t get me wrong – I’m pretty excited that Bette is being taken seriously by a genuine talent in a prestigious title – but I find the Batwoman book pretty breathtaking in all respects.

  5. hgfd says:

    who is kate kane kissing in that last panel??

  6. Pingback: NEW 52: Earth 2 | WTF, DC?

  7. Very interesting! I really wish DC didn’t mess with bringing Betty back at all. Led to way to much confusion. Hopefully New 52 can maybe give the character some justice.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s